Shell Wins Appeal Against Earlier Court Ruling to Cut Emissions

The Dutch Court recently reversed an earlier ruling issued by The Hague Court of Appeals in 2021, favoring the British oil giant, Shell plc SHEL. The ruling issued in 2021 required SHEL to reduce its carbon emissions drastically by about 45% from the base 2019 levels by the end of 2030. The ruling came during the ongoing COP29 climate summit in Azerbaijan and could have a major effect on the future of climate litigations.

The Dutch Court stated that although SHEL was required to reduce emissions, which the company is doing via its net-zero emission target, it could not determine the exact percentage of reduction, dismissing the case entirely.

An Insight Into 2021 Verdict and SHEL’s Arguments

The original decision The Hague Court gave in 2021 was unprecedented as it held SHEL responsible for all the emissions, including those produced from the products they sell, known as Scope 3 emissions. The ruling required the company to comply with the Paris Climate Agreement and reduce CO2 emissions to follow the human right to protection against climate change.

SHEL, on the other hand, argued that it was already working toward its net-zero emissions target and that it was unfair to challenge a single company over a global and broader issue. The company also said that environmental groups should target government bodies to bring about policy changes rather than chasing the corporates.

SHEL, after filing an appeal against the 2021 decision, had relocated its headquarters to the U.K., which was criticized for being done as a result of courtroom defeat.

Effect of Order on Environmentalists

The court’s reversal of the decision brought about a setback for climate advocates. The environmental group Friends of the Earth expressed disappointment over the present ruling while remaining firm for future discourse.

SHEL’s Zacks Rank and Key Picks

London-based Shell is one of the primary oil supermajors - a group of U.S. and Europe-based big energy multinationals with operations that span almost every corner of the globe. Currently, SHEL has a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold).

Investors interested in the energy sector might look at some better-ranked stocks like Mach Natural Resources LP MNR, Enerflex Ltd. EFXTand Flotek Industries, Inc. FTK.While Mach currently sports a Zacks Rank #1 (Strong Buy), Enerflex and Flotek Industries each carry a Zacks Rank #2 (Buy). You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank stocks here.

Mach Natural Resources LP an independent upstream oil and gas company that focuses on the acquisition, development and production of oil, natural gas and natural gas liquids reserves. The Zacks Consensus Estimate for AROC’s 2024 earnings indicates 200% year-over-year growth.

Canada-based Enerflex Ltd. provides oilfield services for natural gas and petroleum producers. EFXT’s expected EPS (earnings per share) growth rate for the next quarter is 188.89%, which compares favorably with the industry loss rate of 22.45%.

Flotek Industries develops and delivers prescriptive chemistry-based technology, including specialty chemicals, to clients in the energy, consumer industrials and food & beverage industries. The Zacks Consensus Estimate for FTK’s 2024 earnings indicates 125% year-over-year growth.

Zacks Investment Research