The September CPI released yesterday (October 13) once again showed the high viscosity of inflation and confirmed that fighting inflation is not an easy task. It is only in the early stage of fighting inflation. There is still a long way to go to defeat inflation. There is little reason for optimism in this CPI report. The core CPI, in particular, has been plagued with many problems. This time these problems are completely exposed, which has set a record since August 1982.
In September, the CPI rose by (expected value: 8.10%, former value: 8.3%) YoY, and grew by 0.4% (expected value: 0.2%, former value: 0.1%) MoM.
Core CPI increased by 6.6% (expected value: 6.5%, former value: 6.3%) YoY, and 0.6% (expected value: 0.5%, former value: 0.6%) MoM.
In terms of overall inflation, energy and food are basically in line with expectations, and the reason why the MoM exceeded expectations is mainly due to the drag of core inflation.
Core inflation, which was mainly driven by core commodities due to the COVID-19 pandemic restriction measures last year, has turned to core services as the main driving force this year. Moreover, as core service inflation is closely related to the labor market and has strong stickiness, its decline will be very slow. This is also why Fed officials are not optimistic when talking about core inflation. Because the U.S. labor market is still strong.
In September, core goods grew 0 MoM (former value: 0.5%), while core services grew 0.8% MoM, the highest level since the COVID-19 pandemic.
Among the core commodities, the price of second-hand cars decreased by 1.1% (former value: -0.1%) MoM, falling for the third consecutive month. The prices of second-hand cars have all dropped significantly recently, and the drop is greater than the average level before the pandemic. On the one hand, the supply of second-hand cars is rebounding, and the prices paid by dealers for inventories have been dropping significantly. On the other hand, according to Cox Automotive, the largest online and offline (O2O) automotive trading platform in the United States, the Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index has seen a relatively large drop recently. High-frequency indicators show that retail prices have also started to drop recently, and the price level is still more than 50% higher than before the pandemic. Therefore, the price of second-hand cars will show a relatively obvious drop in the next three months.
As for new cars, the growth was 0.7% MoM. There was a slight drop from last month, but supply remained severely tight, which limited the extent of the price drop. The price of a new car is more of a supply chain problem than a problem that can be solved in a short period.
Automobiles will be the most extreme example of products hit by the pandemic, accounting for 40% of the core commodities, undoubtedly having the greatest impact on them, and also being the main factor of commodity inflation. The combination of slowing production, the shutdown of overseas factories, the shortage of spare parts, and transportation problems have led to a shortage of cars and a surge in consumer demand for cars. The conflict has pushed prices so high that second-hand and new cars are the main drivers of headline inflation.
If all the large items are put together, core commodities did not contribute to the MoM growth rate of overall inflation in September, while food and energy offset positively and negatively. Therefore, the 0.4% MoM growth rate of overall CPI was entirely driven by core services. In other words, the service sector alone can now sustain a very strong inflation rate (as the 0.4% MoM growth rate is up to 5% for the seasonally adjusted annual rate).
As for core services, as housing inflation, which accounts for one-third of the CPI and half of the core CPI, tenants' rentals and owners' equivalent rentals (OER) increased by 0.8% (former value: 0.7%) and 0.8% (former value: 0.7%) MoM, respectively. On a YoY basis, both climbed to 7.2% and 6.7% respectively, continuing to record their highest levels in decades.
The constant increase in interest rates by the Federal Reserve has led to a constant increase in loan interest rates, which will cause a group of potential home buyers to turn to rent, thus maintaining the prices in the rental market. The current housing demand has weakened significantly as non-seasonal sales have fallen and inventories have increased slightly due to heightened concerns about affordability, which undoubtedly supports rents. In addition, labor demand remains strong, and this imbalance between supply and demand is mainly reflected in strong wage growth. The combination of high rents and housing costs means that housing inflation will remain strong for some time to come.
Forward-looking indicators show that the YoY growth rate of market-based rentals peaked at the beginning of this year, and the MoM growth rate was lower than the high level of 2021 but still higher than the pre-pandemic level. Frankly speaking, the rental item in the CPI is indeed a lagging indicator. As the penetration of market-oriented rentals into the CPI indicator has a long lag, these new changes are not reflected in the data at present. Therefore, although the current popular housing inflation is hardly optimistic, it can still be expected to show signs of slowing down and stabilizing in the future.
Nevertheless, there are two points to keep in mind. First, we only know that market-based rentals are at least six months ahead of CPI rentals. Therefore, the YoY growth rate of CPI rentals may peak this autumn or at the end of the year. It is impossible to predict exactly when the peak will occur. Second, even if the YoY peak occurs, the MoM may remain stabilized. Therefore, even if the CPI rent drops to 0.4-0.5% from 0.6-0.7% MoM, it is still too high, which is quite different from the level corresponding to the 2% inflation target.
On the whole, there is little hope that housing inflation will be improved in a short period, but we can expect it in the future, and we are not clear when it will be improved.
Apart from rentals and volatile economic re-opening services, inflation in other services strengthened further in September, reflecting an overheated labor market and strong wage inflation.
In addition, there is the price of medical services, which has been growing at a rate of about 2% per month for the past 12 months, up from 28.2% in September. Boosted by this sub-item, the average MoM growth rate of the major medical service items in the past 12 months was as high as 0.5%. Fortunately, from October onwards, medical insurance will continue to fall sharply, thus significantly easing the price of medical services (the second most important item in core services).
This is related to the medical insurance preparation method. Since 2018, the U.S. Census Bureau has used the indirect method to measure the cost of health insurance, that is, the cost is indirectly measured by the retained earnings (premium income–expenses reimbursed) of the health insurance company. In other words, when the retained earnings (or profit margin) of a health insurance company rises, the health insurance component in the CPI rises, and vice versa.
However, these data are not available to the Census Bureau every month and can only be obtained after the end of the fiscal year when the U.S. National Association of Insurance Commissioners releases its annual report (in September or October). As a result, there is a lag in the data, and the retained earnings for 2020 will be used to calculate the data for October 2021-September 2022 and the retained earnings for 2021 will be used to calculate the data for October 2022-September 2023.
In 2020, when the premium did not change significantly, the non-urgent need for medical treatment decreased, and retained earnings increased significantly; however, with the re-opening, the reimbursement for medical treatment increased and the retained earnings decreased significantly. As a result, the significant decrease in retained earnings in 2021 will be averaged over the next 12 months of health insurance.
This will slow the rally in core inflation slightly. But it still cannot change the grim pattern of inflation.
Following the beginning of Q4, Halloween, Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve and other major U.S. holidays followed. In particular, the Christmas holiday season, which begins with Black Friday and continues until New Year's Day, will be the peak of consumer demand for goods and services. If inflation rises again next month, it will not come as a surprise.
In addition, the labor shortage problem is likely to intensify again due to the economic and social costs implicit in the new variant of Omicron and the long-term symptoms of COVID-19, adding fuel to the already tight labor market. This will cause stores and companies in the retail industry, for example, to increase their salaries to attract or retain employees. The increase in salaries will also have an impact on inflation.
This inflation report provides the reason for the Federal Reserve to maintain its historic pace of raising interest rates. The data surprised investors and triggered a market crash as concerns grew that continuing inflation would prompt the Fed to take more aggressive action.
Meanwhile, the expectation of a slight slowdown in interest rate hikes previously generated by the minutes of the meeting was once again annihilated. According to the FedWatch Tool tool of CME, the probability of a 50-basis-point interest rate hike by the Federal Reserve in November is 3.7%, the probability of a 75-basis-point interest rate hike is 96.3%, and the probability of a 100-basis-point interest rate hike is 0%. The probability of a 25-basis-point increase in December is 1.0%, the probability of a 50-basis-point increase is 27.6%, and the probability of a 75-basis-point increase is 71.5%.
It is obvious that this inflation report not only nailed down the 75-basis-point interest rate hike in November but also sharply increased the expectation of a 75-basis-point interest rate hike in December. A month ago, the market's expectation of a rate hike in December was only 25 basis points.
However, there will be a "false alarm" in the market's expectation of December's rate hike. For the Federal Reserve, the rate hike path this year has been basically fixed and will not be fundamentally changed due to the September inflation data. The Fed's baseline given at the September FOMC meeting is that it is expected to raise interest rates by 75 basis points in November and 50 basis points in December.
This was also reflected in director Waller's speech on October 6, when Waller said that before the next meeting, there would not be too much new data to make a major adjustment to my views on inflation, employment, and other economic areas. It is expected that most policymakers would feel the same way.
The 75-basis-point rate hike in November is no big surprise. The Fed's task is to eliminate inflation completely. The current inflation trend shows that the problem cannot be fundamentally solved without cooling the labor market. The non-farm payroll data released early this month have already determined the result. Even if the CPI meets expectations, it will still be a 75-basis-point rate hike.
The Fed's bitmap forecast of a 50-basis-point rate hike in December and a further 25-basis-points next year all indicate that the Fed also wants to be more cautious as policy interest rates enter a more restrictive range, making policy adjustments more difficult. This was also reflected in the minutes of this week's meeting, which showed that officials believed it was "important to calibrate the pace of interest rate hikes so as not to have a significant adverse impact on the economic outlook".
Given the popularity of CPI in September, the market is currently expecting a further 75-basis-points hike in December. However, it is still too early to draw a conclusion. There are still two non-farm payrolls and CPI reports between the December meeting. If the non-farm payrolls can continue to cool slowly and the possible slowdown mentioned above can be realized, the Fed will most likely choose to raise interest rates by 50 basis points. On the contrary, if the non-farm payroll sector is still too strong and core inflation keeps rising, the Fed may change its original plan. Meanwhile, the slowdown that should have occurred will be postponed until next year. The original 25-basis-point rate hike may be changed to a 50-basis-point one, and there is a risk that the terminal interest rate will exceed 5%.